FREE SHIPPING to the lower 48 states on orders of $100 or more

Gratitude Without Toxic Positivity: Being Thankful While Acknowledging That Life Can Be Hard

How to practice honest gratitude that leaves room for grief, anger, and exhaustion, with scripts and a simple both-and journal format.

SPIRITUAL & INNER WELL-BEING

10/6/20266 min read

You can be grateful and tired. Thankful and angry. Blessed and grieving. Both halves get to be true.

You say you are exhausted, and someone answers, "At least you have a job." You mention that caring for your mother is wearing you down, and you hear, "You'll miss this someday." You try to be honest about a hard season, and you are handed a reminder to count your blessings.

None of this is cruel. It is usually meant kindly. But it lands like a door closing, and the message underneath is clear: your difficulty is not welcome here.

So a lot of women end up suspicious of gratitude altogether, because it has been used to quiet them. That is a loss, because real gratitude is worth having. It simply looks nothing like forced cheer.

What goes wrong with "just be positive"

Natalie Dattilo, a clinical health psychologist at Brigham and Women's Hospital, has described toxic positivity as stemming from the idea that the best or only way to cope with a bad situation is to put a positive spin on it and not dwell on the negative.

The trouble is that pushing feelings away does not appear to make them leave. In research from the University of California, Berkeley, published in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, psychologists studied more than 1,300 adults across three studies. People who habitually accepted their negative emotions, rather than judging them, reported fewer negative emotions over time and better psychological health.

Senior author Iris Mauss summarized it this way: "We found that people who habitually accept their negative emotions experience fewer negative emotions, which adds up to better psychological health."

Read that twice. The people who let themselves feel bad ended up feeling bad less. The people who scolded themselves for it piled a second bad feeling on top of the first.

What gratitude can really do, and what it cannot

The research on gratitude is encouraging, and more modest than the greeting cards suggest.

Harvard Health describes a well-known experiment by psychologists Robert Emmons and Michael McCullough. For ten weeks, one group wrote a few sentences each week about things they were grateful for, and another wrote about daily irritations. Afterward, the gratitude group was more optimistic and felt better about their lives.

Harvard Health is also frank about the caveats. Studies like these cannot prove cause and effect, and gratitude exercises have not helped everyone who tried them. One study it mentions found that middle-aged divorced women who kept gratitude journals were no more satisfied with their lives than those who did not.

So gratitude is a useful practice, not a cure. It can widen your view on an ordinary hard day. It is not built to carry a crisis, and it was never meant to replace saying, "This is awful."

Four ways gratitude backfires

Psychologist Amie Gordon, writing for the Greater Good Science Center at UC Berkeley, lays out several ways giving thanks can go wrong. Four are especially relevant here.

Overdoing it. In one study she cites, people who wrote in a gratitude journal once a week benefited more than those who wrote three times a week. More is not better, and a daily quota can become a chore you fail at.
Using it to avoid a real problem. Gratitude helps with small annoyances. With serious issues, it can become a way of not dealing with them.
Giving it to the wrong person. Feeling grateful toward someone who treats you badly can keep you in a harmful situation.
Erasing yourself. Thanking everyone else so thoroughly that you leave out your own effort.

The third point deserves plain language. Gratitude is never a reason to stay in a relationship where you are being harmed. "But he's good to me sometimes" is not thankfulness. If you feel unsafe with someone, please reach out to a professional or a support service you trust.

The word that fixes most of it: "and"

Toxic positivity runs on the word "but." "I'm exhausted, but I should be grateful." The "but" cancels the first half.

Swap it for "and."

Canceling ("but" and "at least"): "I'm worn out, but at least I have a job."
- Honest ("and"): "I'm worn out, and I'm glad the job is steady."
Canceling ("but" and "at least"): "It's hard, but other people have it worse."
- Honest ("and"): "It's hard, and I know I have support that others don't."
Canceling ("but" and "at least"): "I shouldn't complain; my kids are healthy."
- Honest ("and"): "I'm thankful my kids are healthy, and I badly need a break."
Canceling ("but" and "at least"): "I miss her, but she lived a long life."
- Honest ("and"): "She lived a long life, and I miss her every day."

Nothing is subtracted in the right-hand column. Both things stand. That is the whole method.

A both-and journal

If you want a written practice, this one takes five minutes and does not ask you to pretend. In line with Gordon's point, once or twice a week is plenty.

Write three lines:

What was hard this week. One or two honest sentences. No softening.
What I am grateful for. One specific thing, with the reason. Not "my family," but "my sister texted to check on me Tuesday, and I felt less alone."
What I did. One thing you handled, carried, or got through. You are allowed to thank yourself.

Specificity is what keeps gratitude from going stale. "My health" turns into a recitation by week three. "My knee didn't hurt on the stairs today" stays alive.

On weeks when line two will not come, leave it blank. A blank line is more honest than a forced one, and honesty is the point.

When someone hands you a silver lining

You do not have to accept it, and you do not have to start an argument. Some replies:

"I know there are good things too. Right now I just need this to be hard for a minute."
"I am grateful for that. It's also true that I'm struggling."
"I'm not looking for the bright side yet. I mostly need someone to listen."
To the persistent: "I'd rather not be cheered up today. Tell me about your week."

And when the silver lining comes from your own head, try: "Both things are true. I don't have to pick."

How not to do it to other people

Most of us have handed out an "at least" without meaning harm. When someone tells you something hard, try these swaps.

Instead of: "Look on the bright side."
- Try: "That sounds really hard."
Instead of: "Everything happens for a reason."
- Try: "I'm so sorry this happened."
Instead of: "At least it wasn't worse."
- Try: "That's a lot to carry."
Instead of: "Stay positive."
- Try: "Do you want ideas, or do you want me to just listen?"
Instead of: "You're so strong."
- Try: "You don't have to be strong with me."

That question, ideas or listening, saves a great many conversations.

Gratitude across beliefs

Gratitude is one of the few practices that almost every tradition shares, and it does not require one.

If you pray, thanksgiving may already be part of it. Many faith traditions also make explicit room for lament, for bringing grief and complaint alongside thanks. The two were never meant to be separated.

If you do not pray, gratitude can simply be attention: noticing something good and letting it register for ten seconds before the day moves on. Thanking a person directly counts too. Harvard Health lists writing a thank-you note, thanking someone mentally, and mindful attention among the ordinary ways to practice.

Whatever your framework, the test is the same. Does this practice make more room for the truth of your life, or less? Keep the kind that makes more.

When it is more than a hard week

Gratitude practices are for the normal ups and downs of a full life. They are not a treatment for depression or anxiety, and struggling to feel thankful is not a moral failure.

If a low mood has lasted for weeks, if you feel numb or hopeless, or if daily life has become difficult to manage, please talk with a doctor or a licensed mental health professional. If you are in the US and are in distress or thinking about harming yourself, you can call or text 988, the Suicide & Crisis Lifeline, at any hour.

Try this today

Catch one "but" or "at least" in your own speech and say it again with "and."
Write your first both-and entry: one hard thing, one specific thing you are grateful for, one thing you did.
The next time someone shares something difficult, ask: "Do you want ideas, or do you want me to just listen?"

You do not owe anyone a cheerful face. You can be thankful for your life and honest about what it costs you, on the same day.